On the other hand, essential oil yields varied during ripening to reach maximum values during the middle stage of maturity (stage 2) for mandarin and orange while the highest lemon yield was found at the beginning of fruit maturation and decreased after that. Bitter orange showed different pattern behaviour evolution from other species since the yield doubled during ripening from 0.23 at stage 1 to 0.46% at stage 3. Vekiari et al. [14] reported a seasonal variation of the yield of lemon peel essential oil extracted from Zambetakis variety cultivated in the island of Crete with the highest value reached at the middle of the season.
Our results concerning the mature stage are in accordance with those of Hosni et al. [15] who demonstrated that Tunisian mandarin peel was the richest on essential oil compared to orange and bitter orange. However, these authors reported higher values (varying from 1.24 to 4.62%). Such differences could be due to the effect of extraction procedure and environmental conditions. In fact, these authors used dried and ground material from citrus cultivated in Mograne region which is known to belong to the semiarid region, while in our experiment we used a fresh material collected from Menzel Bouzelfa which belongs to the humid region. Extractions parameters are known to greatly influence the essential oil yield [18, 19]; moreover, water supply during ripening was reported to influence considerably the essential oil content with an enhancement of the yield under moderate water shortage conditions [20, 21].
On the other hand, the yields obtained in our study were higher than those reported in the literature; Ahmad et al. [22] reported yields varying from 0.30 to 1.21% for the four citrus varieties from Pakistan. Moreover, lower yields were reported for the mandarins from France (yield ranging from 0.05% to 0.60%) by Lota et al. [8] and the mandarin from Colombia (yield of 0.79%) by Blanco Tirado et al. [23].