similar, the smithian transfers are justice preserving in a neighbor hood of the homogeneous situation (that is it say , where holding are roughly equal, Simithian transfers do preserve justice), but when the state (levels of holdings) passes out of that region, in particular when some people begin to have such holding as to constitute capital, the the form of the solution changes, new dynamical forms appear (exploitation and so on), and the resulting solution will no longer be justice preserving.