When visiting Kurt and Rachel in New York, Santana tells Kurt that she can't return to Lima while Brittany is there, since their break-up is very recent. While playing Mrs. Claus at the Mall, a girl comes up to her and sits on her lap. Santana comments that the girl looks exactly like a young Brittany S. Pierce and asks Kurt and Rachel if they agree. Santana explains to little girl that Brittany is his ex-girlfriend who broke up with her, and starts talking excitedly about her relationship with Brittany until she is interrupted by Kurt and Rachel.