Studies of social network site privacy behaviors often highlight the need for better privacy education. In our analysis of interpersonal privacy practices, we identified conversant privacy behaviors as being positively associated with having a friends-only profile. Notably, conversant privacy behaviors do not involve the transmission of technical facts regarding privacy settings, but rather the shared coordination (i.e. turbulence) of profile management between two actors. This everyday practice enhances privacy and may produce greater salience for privacy issues among the user population. Rather than focusing on explaining the complexities of a privacy system to users, perhaps we should design ways to facilitate conversations about everyday privacy behaviors. This may result in the development of privacy enhancing norms such as moving to a friends-only profile.