I also was tutored in close combat by Elinalise.
Though her talent lies in group combat, so in 1v1 she's a bit lacking.
But, after living for so long, she has her share of experience. Until now she has fought many difficult opponents. Even though strength-wise she's middling, she still survived until now.
In my heart, I really wish I could consult Badigadi or Ruijerd for this, but complaining now is pointless.
Perugius won't help either.