Why she might be “A”: Aria has managed to top our list for two weeks in a row! And yes, she continues to raise our suspicions. Like, she implores Ezra to leave town this week — which is exactly what “A” would say to someone who was trying to track “A” down. And we’re still puzzled as to why Aria wouldn’t look at more of Ezra’s clues — unless she had an ulterior motive for destroying everything he’s learned. Hmm.
Why she might not be: Aria continues to act the way a normal girl would after getting her heart broken. And we can’t imagine that “A” could take time off to go shack up with some acoustic guitar-playing dude in Syracuse.