My favorite parts are the analysis of the hat and the final whodunnit with the "What are we going to do about it?" piece. Cummings does a fantastic job reading this story. I felt like he flawlessly transformed himself into all of these distinct characters. I've read this story a few times, but hearing Cummings narrate made me reflect upon the character of Breckinridge. I usually pass him off as a puffy, bit of a bully comic character with necessary information. This reading made me feel a little sorry for Breckinridge. People bothering him and he just wants to make his Christmas sales. And, of course, Cummings' reading of Holmes and Watson is perfect.