Another option you might consider is to keep Marty's secret and tell no one. It is obvious that you believe that telling the truth is extremely important. It is part of your deep faith in God. When you made Marty tell the truth about eating Dara Lynn's treat, you showed how you felt about lying. Omission is another form of lying. You might even feel so guilty that it would change your relationship with your husband and family. Pa also might find out since often goes hunting. He would probably be mad at you at first, but you seem to have strong marriage so he most likely will forgive you. However, there would be some pretty miserable moments first. Guilt is hard to live with.