The Man arrived to find Arwen waiting for him by his door. Aragorn knew he must tell the Lady that his heart laid elsewhere. He could not allow the Evening Star of the Elves to sacrifice her immortality for someone who did not love her. He would not be that selfish, even if Shadow was gone and Arwen would make a great Queen for Gondor. Though Aragorn would prefer to have more time to deliberate his words in order to cause the Lady the least amount of hurt, this occasion would suffice.