Theory Analysis
Are concepts theoretically and operationally defined?
Are statements theoretically and operationally defined?
Are linkages explicit?
Is the theory logically organized?
Is there a model/diagram? Does the model contribute to clarifying the theory?
Are the concepts, statements, and assumptions used consistently?
Are outcomes or consequences stated or predicted?
Theory Evaluation
Is the theory congruent with current nursing standards?
Is the theory congruent with current nursing interventions or therapeutics?
Has the theory been tested empirically? Is it supported by research? Does it appear to be accurate/valid?
Is there evidence that theory has been used by nursing educators, nursing researchers, or nursing administrators?
Is the theory socially relevant?
Is the theory relevant cross-culturally?
Does the theory contribute to the discipline of nursing?
What are implications for nursing related to implementation of the theory?