Rogoff (Journal of Economic Literature 1996;34:647–668) describes the ‘remarkable consensus’ of 3–5 year half-lives of purchasing power parity deviations among studies using long-horizon data. These studies, however, focus on rejections of unit roots in real exchange rates and do not use appropriate techniques to measure persistence. Our half-life estimates explicitly account for serial correlation, sampling uncertainty and, most importantly, small sample bias. Calculating confidence intervals as well as point estimates for long-horizon and post-1973 data, we find that, even though most of the point estimates lie within the 3–5 year range, univariate methods provide virtually no information regarding the size of the half-lives.