What the judges said: A general thumb's up from Jennifer Lopez, Keith Urban and Harry Connick Jr. "It really felt good today," Lopez said. Connick noted that Roberts covered the song in "a basic way," but said it worked just fine. Connick seemed to be basking in the afterglow of last week's performance, adding that Roberts "could do no wrong" after that. Urban offered a few tips for guitar-slinging on stage, recommending that Roberts kick out the jams and surprise the audience.