The reader must have observed the painful care which the writer has had to take in order to state his paradoxes. The least slip in the statement of propositions ostensibly self-referring will break the charmed circle. This, of course, is usually true of logical fallacies. They are extremely hard to put. Correspondingly, it is also difficult to be sure that we have not fallen into fallacy. This is why renvoi has always been a logical ghost not easy to lay; and the value of the fore- going analysis, if any it have, lies in its making precise the logical difficulties in the doctrine.
When reference back is resorted to, the analysis indicates that there will be no logical difficulty if the reference is back to internal law. On the other hand, reference back to the conflicts rule lands us on the logical merry-go-round. The immediate practical result of this analysis is that the logical kinks in the ordinary doctrine of renvoi can be ignored. In every such instance either the internal law of the forum or foreign
internal law may be applied to the case so far as logic is concerned. Thus the whole field of choice of law is freed from the logical bugbear that has so long haunted it; and as has already been said, juridical rather than logical considerations should determine one's attitude
toward the doctrine
The reader must have observed the painful care which the writer has had to take in order to state his paradoxes. The least slip in the statement of propositions ostensibly self-referring will break the charmed circle. This, of course, is usually true of logical fallacies. They are extremely hard to put. Correspondingly, it is also difficult to be sure that we have not fallen into fallacy. This is why renvoi has always been a logical ghost not easy to lay; and the value of the fore- going analysis, if any it have, lies in its making precise the logical difficulties in the doctrine.When reference back is resorted to, the analysis indicates that there will be no logical difficulty if the reference is back to internal law. On the other hand, reference back to the conflicts rule lands us on the logical merry-go-round. The immediate practical result of this analysis is that the logical kinks in the ordinary doctrine of renvoi can be ignored. In every such instance either the internal law of the forum or foreigninternal law may be applied to the case so far as logic is concerned. Thus the whole field of choice of law is freed from the logical bugbear that has so long haunted it; and as has already been said, juridical rather than logical considerations should determine one's attitudetoward the doctrine
การแปล กรุณารอสักครู่..
