Every now and then there is a pop culture moment so huge, it forces a semi-dormant fan base to roar back to life. The Buffyverse recently experienced one of these massive in-community controversies when former Buffy star Sarah Michelle Gellar was asked during a Reddit AMA if she was Team Angel or Team Spike.
Had the internet been as omnipresent when Buffy the Vampire Slayer originally aired (from 1997–2003), this question would have been asked and answered a zillion times over, so fans of Joss Whedon’s seminal series were glued to their computer screens as Gellar typed, in all caps, “ANGEL.”
Angel, played with a brooding intensity by David Boreanaz, was Buffy’s first love, but subsequent seasons paired The Slayer — somewhat controversially — with James Marsters’ Spike, an unapologetically bloodthirsty vampire whose redemption became a driving force in the show’s final years. The fandom had long been split over who was truly worthy of Buffy’s heart, but with five letters, Gellar let us all know where she stood.
“Well, I have to say, I really messed with her a lot, so perhaps there’s more to her choice than just what happened on the show,” Marsters told BuzzFeed during a recent interview. “I grew up as a subversive artist, and you have to be so polite to the lead on a film all the time — whether they’re nice or not — so something about that stuck in my craw and I would, sometimes, lovingly mess with her. It’s mean, but I couldn’t help myself. So, maybe I understand why she said that.”
Marsters also understands why, more than a decade after the series finale, he’s still approached on a near-daily basis about his role on the WB (and later UPN) series. “I didn’t write Buffy, I didn’t produce Buffy, I didn’t direct Buffy, so I’m not bragging when I say it was a really good show,” he stated. “I stood on tape and wore the hair and scowled in the correct manner, so I’m just glad to have been a part of it. But I always knew that even after the special effects got a little old-looking, generations would appreciate this. I remember telling Sarah that we may go on to lots of money later in our careers, but we would never touch the nerve of the world like we are today.”