Gubler divides his time between Los Angeles, Las Vegas, and New York City.[16]
In 2009 Gubler dislocated his knee while dancing. The injury required three surgical procedures and the use of a cane for nearly a year.[17]
On October 27, 2014, Gubler became an ordained minister.[18] He performed the wedding of former Criminal Minds star Paget Brewster and his best friend, Steve Damstra, on November 29, 2014.[19]