EDUARDO
This book is quite exciting.Even after the first few pages you want to know who killed the woman,and you don't know until the end.It's well written and the characters are really interesting and realistic. However,the story is quite hard to follow because there are so many different people,so I didn't enjoy it as much as I expected.
KATIE
This is the best book I've ever read in English! It's a beautiful story,although it's also very sad and it made me cry. The man and woman are wonderful characters and they are described very well. You can really understand how they feel. I definitely recommend it!
TINA
This book is OK,but it's not brilliant. The story is quite interesting and it's easy to read However, it's not very exciting, because you know from the start that the girl and her friend will save the girl's father from the storm and they will all live happily ever after. I also thought the will all live happily ever after. I also thought the characters were a bit dull. In real life, people are not good and kind all of the time!
WOO-JIN
I really enjoyed this book. It was interesting to read and it describes Edinburgh very well, so you can really imagine what the city and the people are like. Although the story is quite complicated, you should keep going because the ending is very clever. You can't guess who killed the woman until the very last page. I could,t put the book down until I got to the end! I can recommend it.