Reckless USDA decision to approve Arctic apples could decimate the US apple industry
Like with nearly every other previous GMO approval, there are a number of important factors that weren't even considered by the USDA. One of these is Okanagan's failure to evaluate how the PPO gene functions in an apple other than just browning it. By switching this gene "off," a chain effect may occur that results in the apple becoming poisonous, for instance, either to animals, pollinators or humans -- or perhaps all of these.
"This decision is scientifically irresponsible and misguided," stated Dr. Doug Gurian-Sherman, a senior scientist at CFS. "The agency has failed to analyze whether suppressing fruit browning with these novel RNAs impacts the rest of the gene family in the tree, or whether there are off-target impacts on other genes."
A number of recent studies, including this one published in the journal Environment International back in 2013, reveal that RNAi tweaking that supposedly targets just one gene may inadvertently affect other genes as well, turning them on or off in unpredictable or unanticipated ways.
"This product is completely unnecessary and poses numerous risks to apple growers, the food industry and consumers," added Andrew Kimbrell, executive director of CFS, about the decision. "For USDA to turn a blind eye to these risks for such an inessential technological 'advance' is foolish and potentially costly."
The only safe food these days is non-US food that hasn't been tampered with
If only avoiding this transgenic monstrosity were as simple as just not buying it. But the sad reality is that, like with other GMOs currently grown in the U.S., the potential for cross-contamination is almost a given. Bees, butterflies and other pollinators will surely visit Arctic apple trees and carry their pollen to non-GMO and organic apple trees, contaminating the entire stock.
Perhaps not surprising is the disturbing fact that Arctic apples, which were developed in Canada, won't be grown anywhere in Canada, at least for now. Only the U.S. has deregulated their commercial cultivation, which more than 520 commercial tree fruit growers just in the Okanagan region of Canada have opposed in order to protect their crops.
"The USDA has let down U.S. apple growers and the public by wasting resources on this useless and risky food," says EcoWatch. "To make matters worse, these apples will not be required to be labeled and consumers will not know that the sliced apples they pack in their children's lunches were made through genetic engineering.