Calculated based on: the Tax Report Form of the Republic of Dagestan, analytical memorandums regarding
receipt of tax payments, tax indebtedness, and activity of the Department of the Federal Tax Service of the
Russian Federation in the Republic of Dagestan during 2010-2013; official reporting of the Department of the
Federal Tax Service of the Russian Federation in the Republic of Dagestan, website: www.r05.nalog.ru.
Analysis of the results of evaluating the efficiency of tax relieves in the Republic of Dagestan during the period
of 2010-2013 evidences existence of multiple problems of both legal regulation and of executive and
organizational nature. There are inconsistencies and contradictions in the effective legal acts of the Republic ofDagestan governing calculation of the efficiency of tax relieves. Thus, in accordance with the Law of the
Republic of Dagestan dated 07.04.2009 #22 "On evaluation of the socioeconomic efficiency of tax relieves
granted to certain categories of taxpayers, the tax relief has positive fiscal efficiency if the sum of the actual
(planned) tax revenues to the national budget of the Republic of Dagestan due to granting the tax relieves is
greater than or equal to the amount of the granted (planned for granting) tax relieves. However, according to the
order of evaluation of the efficiency of tax relieves provided by the Order of the Government of the Republic of
Dagestan dated 25.06.2008 #207-A, the relieves can be provided (kept effective) if the value of the budgetary
efficiency ratio is greater than one. In order to bring the Order of the Government of the Republic of Dagestan
dated 25.06.2008 #207-A in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Dagestan dated 07.04.2009 #22, it is
necessary to specify the conditions for recognition of budgetary efficiency of a relief – if the value of the
budgetary efficiency ratio is greater than or equal to one (Musaeva, 2014).