According to the Implementation Evaluation Report of 2005/6, the success rate was at 30%. This means that
appraisal forms were sometimes not filled out; the forms were sometimes not available, and when provided were photocopies; appraisals were not conducted at appointed times; employees who were supposed to conduct self-appraisals were denied that opportunity; performance targets were either dictated by the superior or expected
by the junior and not jointly agreed upon; no feed back; sometimes there was too limited knowledge about the appraisals.