I'm interesting in knowing what readers look for in a poem. Do you like the emotion? How about allusions to myths? Or do you prefer a poem that plays over and over in your head long after you've finished reading it? Personally, I like poems that have a good sound to them. The Garden of Proserpine is an excellent example: the rhyme scheme is just amazing. And I've yet to read a poem that excited me as much on a first read through as Poe's The Bells did.