There is the growing demand by all stakeholders (teachers, students, employers, governments, and society) for universities and colleges to be more accountable in preparing their products for the challenges of the 21 st century. Such demands have fueled interest in the evaluation of student learning in virtually all disciplines in college. There are calls for pedagogic innovations that will improve student learning in college. If any success can be achieved in addressing the challenge of improving the quality of products from higher education, then colleges and universities have need for reliable data. Such data can be obtained partly through an effective process of evaluation that allows for the examination of clear indicators of program quality and the effect on student learning. It is with this in mind that I embarked on this study that relied on the perceptions of some key stakeholders to evaluate the performance of an undergraduate accounting program in a private university in Ghana.