I can tell you everything. It is as clear in my mind as if it happened just last night. As I have said, our house is very old and we live in only one wing of it. Dr. Roylott's bedroom is the First, Julia's is the second and mine m is the third. There are no doors connecting the rooms. They just open out into the same long hall. That night, Dr. Roylott went to his room early. We knew he hadn't gone to sleep because Julia could smell his cigars. He tended to smoke cigars in his room."
Julia always hated that smell. So she came to my room. We talked for quite a while mainly about her wedding. At about 11 p.m., she got up to go back to her room. Just as she was leaving, she asked "Do you ever hear any whistling in the early hours of the morning? I told her that I had never heard anything. the Then she asked me if I whistled in my sleep.