student opinion of efficiency to the managerial of doctoral curriculum in private and public higher education institutions for the doctoral curriculum opening on average is high to highest. For pattern of doctoral studying on average is high to highest . For assessment on average is hight to highest. For class attendant operation on average high to highest.For doctoral research and study on average is high to highest.For the study expend on average is hight all 7 sides on average is hight to highest. For the opinion of executive to the efficiency of managerial doctoral curriculum on average high.