If a player in the circle thinks they have caught the Gotcha in the act of winking at another player, he or she says "I suspect.” They are the first suspecter. All playing then pauses and another player must say "I second suspect" in support of the first person who suspects. (The second suspecter may not know who the Gotcha is, but must trust the judgment of the person who first suspects.) The first suspecter then names who they think is the Gotcha. If they are correct, that player wins. If not, then both the first and second suspecter must drop out and play continues. If the Gotcha is successful in eliminating all but the last player, the Gotcha wins.