When Taylor Swift got together with Twilight hottie Taylor Lautner, whom she met while filming Valentine's Day, we thought she'd finally have a reason to write a (happy) love song. Turns out Taylor Squared didn't add up to lasting love. True to form, Swift wrote a couple songs about their breakup, "Back To December" and "The Story Of Us," which is supposedly about running into Taylor at an awards show and feeling so sad and alone because they were no longer dating. “I think both of us had so much that we wanted to say, but we’re sitting six seats away from each other, just fighting this silent war of ‘I don’t care that you’re here,'" she told New York magazine at the time. Poor Tay—and Tay!