I finally got 2 stars with:
White mid-sleeve shirt with puffy sleeves and bow (9 gems)
Blue shorts that are in the closet, not the belted ones
Short blonde hair that's in the closet
Fedora hat that's in the closet
White and gold clutch
Tan colored stockings
Red lipstick from the closet
Brown eye-shadow that goes all around the eye
Purple gem earrings from the closet
Pink gem necklace from the closet
Purple glasses from the closet
Black and gold heels
Natural blush
Gold watch from the closet