Wow, I haven’t gotten my order yet, but I ordered this set because NARS described it as “iconic nudes for every mood” in “Sheer Dusty Rose, Dusty Rose, Pink Rose”. Honestly, in your swatches, I don’t think it looks like shades of rose; maybe a super light warm plum as you describe. I agree with you they do look warm-toned which is kind of a bummer for me since I was hoping they were either neutral/nude as described by NARS or even cool (which is how they looked on my monitor). Either way, they appear as if they are totally not the Fall transitions shades I was hoping for. Serves me right – I knew I should have waited for your review! (I do think I’ll get some better use from these in the spring.)