The first step is choose a thick cut of steak over a thin one. Thick cuts of steak can develop a beautiful outer crust without drying out the insides unnecessarily. This task is a lot more difficult with thin cuts. If you like your steak to have a perfectly-brown outside and a juicy, pink center, opt for thicker cuts of meat over thinner ones. Ensure the steak is defrosted first, an icy steak won't season or sear properly.