Probably the best option of the three is to take Shiloh back to the house, show it to Marty's father, and explain the situation to him as best you can. You have a very good relationship with your husband and he listens to you. Even though he feels strongly about property, he might help to think of another solution besides giving the dog back to Judd. Because you have told the truth, you would not feel guilty. Marty would see that the truth is very important because you are a good role model. Although Shiloh might have to go back to Judd, Marty's father might be more understanding about the situation and he might tell Judd that he is going to be watching to see if he hurts Shiloh.