For eye shadow, use only natural tones such as browns, tans or even nude pinks. No purple, blue or other unnatural colours unless it is required for character purposes. For a show like Godspell, your director will want girls to have brighter colors on the eyes, and even glitter on eyes and cheeks in addition to the blush/eyeshadow to be able to catch the light. Start with a light skin tone and gently cover the area of skin below your brow. Then, put a medium shade of brown on the eyelid and sweep it up and out. Next, line your crease with a darker brown and your tear duct with a white colour.