1. Using the listed alternatives, prepare a comparative analysis for the following tooling problem: Six
hundred and twenty five flange plates require four holes accurately drilled 90 degrees apart to mate
with a connector valve. (20 point)
Alternative:
a. Have a machinist, earning $10.00 per hour, layout and drill each part at a rate of two minutes
per part.
b. Use a template jig, capable of producing 45 parts per hour and costs of template jig $20.00, in
the production department, where an operator earns $6.50 per hour.
c. Use a duplex jig, which costs $40.50 and can produce a part every 22 seconds, in the production
department, where an operator earns $6.50 per hour.
Determine economic & productivity factors of each alternative and complete the comparing the
alternatives table below