7.4. The United States submits that MOFCOM could have provided an average of absolute values per year in the tables, instead of percentage changes. This would have given US respondents a reasonable understanding of the substance of the confidential information. 53 The United States contends in this regard that reading the percentage changes contained in some of the tables in conjunction with the trend lines in the non-confidential summaries at issue does not remedy these inconsistencies, insofar as both elements are themselves inconsistent with Articles 6.5.1 and 12.4.1.