Managers’ relative accuracy in predicting the choices of seniors does not depend on whether the seniors are top or mediocre (p>.377), and we obtain results similar to our main analyses when we use the average managers’ accuracy in predicting the choices made by the two paired auditors (top and mediocre seniors).We repeat our analyses to assess whether differential familiarity with the paired auditor (measured by taking the average of the three familiarity measures described in Section 3.2; Cronbach’s alpha=.501) directly affects or interacts with job level to determine predictive accuracy. We obtain similar results, and find no main or interaction effects of familiarity for either the bad-debt task (p>.512) or the control-weakness task (p>.285).