Table 4 reports the results of the regression of returns on earnings and cash flows variables simultaneously. In the pre-crisis period, only the coefficient of earnings is statistically significant and is larger than that in the crisis and post-crisis periods. However, the coefficient of cash flows is not significant during the pre-crisis period, but becomes positively significant in the post-crisis
period (γ4 = 0.44). The coefficient of change in cash flows is also statistically significant during the crisis period (γ5 = 0.35). The findings indicate that the value relevance of earnings declines while the value relevance of cash flows increases over the periods when the two measures are