However, as we have already suggested, programmes like this are constructed
upon very inadequate appreciations of dialect variation - which
includes pronunciation and syntax differences, as well as lexical variation.
Bereiter and Engelmann have been criticized by Labov, who is well-known
for his demonstration of the linguistic validity of Black English Vernacular
(1973, 1976). This rather undercuts the philosophy of intervention and
compensatory language programmes for the pre-school child since there is,
in effect, nothing for which to compensate.
However, as we have already suggested, programmes like this are constructedupon very inadequate appreciations of dialect variation - whichincludes pronunciation and syntax differences, as well as lexical variation.Bereiter and Engelmann have been criticized by Labov, who is well-knownfor his demonstration of the linguistic validity of Black English Vernacular(1973, 1976). This rather undercuts the philosophy of intervention andcompensatory language programmes for the pre-school child since there is,in effect, nothing for which to compensate.
การแปล กรุณารอสักครู่..
