This case was brought into the proceedings at the WTO by India, Malaysia, Pakistan and Thailand due to the US legislation in the United States is Section 609 of US Public Law101-162 which stipulates that the requirement. Shrimp caught with technologies that may pose a direct impact on sea turtles may not be imported into the United States. And requiring fishermen to catch shrimp using turtle excluder device (TEDs) Appellate Body consider that the measures banning imports of US contrary to GATT 1994 Article XI, and although such measures, the United States will be an exception. The chapter on Article XX (g) is a measure that is going to conserve natural resources that may become extinct or depletion