This article discusses the findings of an engineering evaluation of fire damage to precast, prestressed concrete members in a parking structure. The study consisted of two phases: a materials-engineering phase, including in-place and laboratory testing of concrete-core specimens, and a load-testing phase to verify load-carrying capacity of fire-damaged members. The materials-engineering phase (phase I) consisted of in-place, nondestructive testing of concrete cores and subsequent testing of flexural strength and dynamic modulus of elasticity of concrete-core specimens. The nondestructive and laboratory testing findings indicated a compromise in the concrete’s modulus of elasticity and, therefore, the flexural stiffness directly above the fire in two double-tees. Based on this finding, the two fire-damaged precast concrete double-tees were load tested in phase II of the evaluation. An analytical model of the fire-damaged double-tees was developed to confirm the deflection pattern. The analytical model, which incorporated the loss of stiffness EI due to midspan flexural cracking and the fire, was used to calculate theoretical deflections. The analytical model served as validation of the findings and improved the level of confidence in the subsequent engineering recommendations. The structure was returned to service after completion of the engineering evaluation.