This paper is solve optimal coordination relay to verify the effectiveness of the propose artificial bees colony (ABC)are setting parameter of objective function in (4) are follow wI = 1, w2 = 100 and w3= 100. For comparison purposes Quasi-Newton (BFGS), particle swarm optimization (PSO) and artificial bees colony (ABC) were used in the system. Table II illustrates optimal time dial setting (TDS) and pickup current (Ip) of each relay of case study. The results is not over boundary and computational time to obtain optimal solution is shown in Table III. Each method was comparative optimal coordination problem of 30 trials randomly, Minimum, Average, Maximum and Standard deviation of 30 solution are evaluated are show in Table III result for 9 bus system study.