Dear people. I think it is wiser for us not to assume based on Josh's words only. In this case we only see a glimpse of Josh's point of view, and we never get to see Niall's or Mel's which may be slightly or massively different. I am not saying Josh is lying, only that I have been in such situation before, and I have learned that people will always have THEIR OWN version of truth. And anyone would DEFEND THEMSELVES. I believe in reasons behind every situatuon. It is wrong to judge people (Niall and Mel) based on only one person (Josh) opinion. And may I say it could be not objective as he is related to the situation. Please dont act like we know the whole story. Never mouth off a situation that we haven't endured. Xx