Both performers should enter the best actor and actress conversations. Edgerton, who previously received good notices for his violent Tom Buchanan in The Great Gatsby and his conflicted FBI agent inBlack Mass, plays Richard Loving as a man of few words, who keeps his eyes down and his emotions bottled up. Negga, though not as familiar to American audiences, plays the more optimistic half of the couple, rooted to the land and protective of her three children.
Variety also thinks Loving “will inevitably factor heavily in year-end Oscar conversations.” However, its critic praised the film while also describing it as “too damn polite.” Vanity Fair agreed “there’s something troublingly inert about Loving.”
The Oscars will probably eat it up either way, since the Academy is no doubt looking to rebound from the whiteness of last year. THR notes that “while Loving...is likely to be lumped together with other films that could help the Academy avoid a replay of #OscarsSoWhite, it really shouldn’t be viewed as part of some sort of affirmative action initiative.”