While confronting the Crooked Man in his lair, Bigby learns that both Faith and Lily's murders were committed by Georgie, though he implies that he did so under the Crooked Man's orders. When Bigby later speaks with Georgie in the Pudding & Pie. he reveals that Faith, Lily and Nerissa "tried to pull a runner" on him and the Crooked Man. As a result, the crime lord ordered Georgie to silence the girls.