I have never eaten Vegemite—should I try it? I currently have no children—should I
apply to adopt a child? In each case, one might imagine, whichever choice I make, I can
make it rationally by appealing to the principles of decision theory. Not always, says L. A.
Paul. In Transformative Experience, Paul issues two challenges to decision theory based upon
examples such as these [Paul, 2014]. I will show how we might reformulate decision theory
in the face of these challenges. Then I will consider the philosophical questions that remain
after the challenges have been accommodated.