Thirty-two (71%) of 45 dogs showed fear in one or both stimulus conditions. Twenty-one (66%) of them showed fear toward both the fake and real dogs, eight (25%) dogs showed fear toward the fake dog only and only three(9%) dogs showed fear toward the live dog only. The fearful trait demonstrated only moderate agreement between the two stimulus conditions with an observed agreement of 76% (34/45). Positive agreement was 0.79 and negative agreement