If you make Marty take Shiloh back to Judd and not tell Pa that you found him, there are several negative consequences and not too many positive ones. Most likely your husband would find out. After all, he is a postman and they visit with everyone. He feels strongly about the fact that Shiloh belongs to Judd and he would be embarrassed in front of Judd. Being so mean and cruel, Judd might have Marty arrested, although he often breaks the law by killing deer out of season. Judd might even kill Shiloh. He has a history of abusing his dogs and has threatened to break Shiloh's legs if he found him.