The articles for which you are not a discussion leader, you must prepare 3 critical questions and 3 constructive comments that you would have liked to have given the authors of the paper if you were a reviewer. These questions and comments must be typed and submitted along with your summary. A failure to do so will have a significant impact on your ability to participate in our discussions. Overall, your class participation grade will be based on the quality of your comments as contributions to the discussion and the consistency with which you make them throughout the semester.