The aim of this paper is to determine whether, in addition to a tourist’s stated satisfaction with different attributes, certain negative situations or characteristics can have a bearing on his/her overall impression of a destination. In particular, this study has two specific objectives. The first one is to examine whether attribute survey responses are coherent regardless of whether the question underscores a degree of satisfaction or a degree of dissatisfaction. In other words, we want to ascertain whether tourists rate the aspects of a destination the same way, irrespective of whether such aspects are evaluated by means of questions pertaining to satisfaction or which explicitly ask about the things that they did not like. The lack of concordance between the two types of evaluations would make it necessary to use different dimensions to gather the expressions of satisfaction and dissatisfaction. The second objective of this study is to determine the influence of dissatisfaction dimensions on tourists’ overall satisfaction and on their intention to return.