Juli Kidman encounters Joseph yet again in The Consequence. His reappearance surprises Kidman, who thought she had killed him earlier. Like in the main game, Juli seems to fatally shoot Joseph when he gets in the way of her trying to kill Leslie. However, Joseph seems to have survived as Juli encounters the bodies of everyone connected to the STEM later on. The bodies of Joseph, Juli and Sebastian still had a heartbeat while the deceased Marcelo and Oscar did not, implying that he is still alive.