the "jock girl" of the group. Emily was closest to Alison before her disappearance and was also in love with her. A closeted lesbian, Emilly was later outed by "A". She also falls in love with and dates Maya St. Germain. During this time, she also befriends Toby, Jenna Marshall's step-brother, even though she was distrustful of him at first. In Season Three. Emily was still distraught about her past girlfriend Maya's death but then begins dating her teammate on the swim team, Paige McCullers.